Judith P. HALLETT Listening to the First, Speaking to the Twenty-First Centuries
Before I joined the academic specialists
advising the writers and producers of 'The First Century in the Roman
Empire,' a documentary series produced for public television, I had
previously taken part in severalc ommercial projects that sought to
represent the classical world for a broadly constituted audience.
Among them were a documentary for ABC-TV Sports, a series for the
Discovery Channel, and various programs produced under the auspices
of the History Channel. It was rewarding to work with the creators of
these commercial projects, since they had considerable enthusiasm for
classical antiquity. Yet they often regarded serious research and
thoughtful analysis as of lesser importance than communicating fairly
simple and, where possible, sensationalist messages to suit agendas
that had been made up in advance,agendas they thought would 'sell' to
their sponsors and 'wow' their target audiences. Interview questions,
formulatedand posed by staffers, were sometimes informed by markedly
presentist concerns, with mixed results. Some of these programs
ultimately gave a misleading impression of ancient Greek and Roman
society and conveying an insufficient sense of new developments in
scholarship and approaches to evidence.
I had, however, also served as an 'expert
witness' on four different classically-themed episodes of a public
radio program, the Canadian Broadcasting Company's 'Court of Ideas.'
Co-authored by the learned and imaginative Trevor Hodge of Carleton
University (who also conducted carefully prepared interviews with
witnesses such as myself before integrating them into his script),
each episode spotlighted the relevant ancient texts and current
research on them. Hodge's more historically responsible approach
served his material and listeners well, without any loss of
entertainment value. Consequently I was pleased to learn that the
creative minds behind 'The First Century' shared several of Hodge's
assumptions, and had indeed worked on the award-winning television
documentary series 'The Great War.'
Publicly funded by a grant from the National
Endowment for the Humanities, and aired on both PBSand the BBC, 'The
Great War' searched out first-person accounts, obscure or well known,
of the events treated in each episode. Therefore,as Jay Winter has
observed,'storytelling created both the narrative flow and the
analytic force, from the accumulation of insights through personal
testimony.' The writers and producers of 'The First Century' have
also chosen to adapt this method for portraying the cultural milieu
of early imperial Rome and have also obtained funding support from
the NEH. To judge from the success of 'The Great War,' affording
twenty-first century audiences the opportunity to listen to voices
from the first century of the Roman empire will enhance the impact as
well as the quality of this television series.